Grandma always said the best part of a cheese is the part people throw away. She wasn’t the first to say it. A bishop told the same thing to Charlemagne, more than eleven hundred years ago.
The emperor and the bishop’s cheese
The story comes from The Deeds of Charlemagne, written by a monk known as Notker the Stammerer for Charlemagne’s great-grandson, between 884 and 887 (Medievalists.net).
Charlemagne, traveling on a Friday when he ate no meat, stopped at a bishop’s house. The bishop had nothing grand to offer, only cheese. The emperor took his knife and carefully cut away the moldy part. The bishop, standing nearby like a servant, stepped closer and asked why: “You are throwing away the very best part” (translation of Notker). Charlemagne tried the moldy part, liked it, and ordered two cartloads of that cheese delivered to his palace every year (Merovingian World).
Was it Roquefort? People love to say so, and others say Brie. Honestly, nobody knows: Notker never names the cheese, and historians point out that the story fits neither one neatly (Merovingian World). What it does show is the old way of making cheese: aged slowly, with its mold and rind left on, and nothing thrown away.
The cheese a king protected
Roquefort’s own story is better documented. On 4 June 1411, King Charles VI of France granted the people of Roquefort-sur-Soulzon a monopoly on ripening the cheese, as they had already been doing for centuries (Wikipedia: Roquefort).
The blue comes from a mold, Penicillium roqueforti, found in the soil of the village’s caves (Wikipedia: Roquefort). Copies followed, of course. In 1666 the Parlement of Toulouse confirmed that only the people of Roquefort could mature cheese in the village caves, and set penalties for counterfeits made nearby (Wikipedia: Roquefort-sur-Soulzon).
Then and now
| Then | Now |
|---|---|
| 1411: royal letters protect Roquefort’s caves | EU law: only cheese aged in the natural Combalou caves of Roquefort-sur-Soulzon may be called Roquefort |
| 1666: penalties for fakes | In the United States, “Roquefort” is a certification mark for sheep’s milk cheese from those caves (Cheese Connoisseur) |
It’s the third of the old rules that still guard your groceries: honest weight, honest ingredients, and an honest name.
On a low-carb table
A little real blue cheese goes a long way: crumbled over a green salad with walnuts, on celery sticks, or melted over a steak. Check the label for the name and, on Roquefort, the sheep’s milk. Store it wrapped in waxed or cheese paper in the fridge, so it can breathe without drying out.
Grandma’s verdict: Read the name on the label, and don’t cut off the best part. A bishop told Charlemagne so, and he listened.