Grandma remembered churning butter as a child. You don’t need a churn: a jar, a mixer or a food processor does the job in minutes, and it’s a wonderful thing to do with children.
What you need: 2 cups of heavy cream, ideally cold, a pinch of salt (optional), and a bowl of ice water.
How to make it
- Whip it past whipped cream. Pour the cream into a mixer or a large jar with a tight lid. Mix on medium-high, or shake hard. It turns to whipped cream, then stiff and grainy, then suddenly splits into yellow butter and thin liquid.
- Pour off the buttermilk. Save it in the fridge for marinating chicken or making dressing.
- Wash the butter. Press the butter together in the bowl of ice water and knead it with a spatula. Pour off the cloudy water and repeat until the water runs clear. Leftover buttermilk is what makes homemade butter sour quickly.
- Press out the water and work in a pinch of salt if you like.
- Wrap it and refrigerate it.
How much you get: 2 cups of cream gives roughly a stick and a half of butter and about a cup of buttermilk, depending on the cream.
Keep it cold. Homemade butter has no preservatives. Keep it in the fridge, wrapped, and freeze what you won’t use within a couple of weeks.
Grandma’s verdict: Once you’ve made your own, you’ll never think of butter as just something in a box again.